New

Bangkok 2026 Street Food Guide is live — read the full guide

Food Place Passport

Papa Johns Pizza in Indiana

Discover a relaxed atmosphere at Papa Johns Pizza on N Michigan St, offering a simple setting for enjoying quality pizza in Plymouth.

3.8 203 reviews $ Pizza Restaurant American · Southern

1625 N Michigan St, Plymouth, IN 46563

FoodPlacee Passport United States · Indiana · 9502
Verified

Papa Johns Pizza

Plymouth, Indiana, USA

Rating★ 3.8 / 5
Price$
CategoryPizza Restaurant
Today 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM

Overview

About This Food Place

Papa Johns Pizza in Plymouth, IN, is a pizza take-out and delivery chain known for classic and specialty pizzas, accompanied by a variety of wings, sides, and desserts. The casual spot is perfect for those craving comfort food with quick service and affordable prices.

Conveniently located at 1625 N Michigan St, this pizza restaurant offers multiple service options including no-contact delivery, onsite dining, and takeout. Its welcoming atmosphere and accessible facilities make it a reliable choice for lunch or dinner, any day of the week.

Gallery

Photos from Papa Johns Pizza

Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.

View all photos

Local favorites

Why People Come Here

Known for its flavorful pizzas and convenient services, this spot attracts many local pizza lovers in Plymouth.

Delicious Classic & Specialty Pizzas

A variety of hand-tossed pizzas with fresh ingredients, including flavorful specialty options and popular thin crust choices.

Multiple Service Options

Offers no-contact delivery, takeout, onsite counter service, and reliable delivery to fit busy schedules.

Casual Atmosphere & Convenience

The casual setting and counter service make it perfect for quick lunches or casual dinners without the wait.

Accessible for Everyone

Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot ensure easy access for guests with mobility needs.

Comfort Food Anytime

Famous for pizza, wings, sides, and desserts that satisfy late-night cravings or family meals alike.

Convenient Location & Parking

Located on N Michigan St with free parking options, making pick-up or dine-in hassle-free.

Experience

When & How to Enjoy This Place

Ideal for a quick bite or a relaxed meal, this location fits well into busy schedules and casual dining occasions.

With hours stretching until midnight every day, Papa Johns Pizza offers a convenient spot for fast, flavorful meals combined with a friendly, casual atmosphere and a menu that caters to late-night cravings. — FoodPlacee editorial note

Quick Lunch Spot

Perfect for a speedy lunch break with pizza, wings, and sides ready to grab or enjoy onsite without the wait.

Late-Night Cravings

Open until midnight, this place serves comfort food late into the evening, ideal for night owls craving a savory snack or meal.

Family Dinner Takeout

Order a variety of pizzas, wings, and desserts for a casual family meal at home, with convenient delivery and takeout options available.

Contactless Delivery

Enjoy a safe and easy ordering experience through the app, making meals accessible right to the doorstep.

Casual Group Dining

Gather friends for a no-fuss pizza night under a casual setting, enjoying counter service with no reservations required.

Best for

Lunch Dinner Late Night Takeout Delivery Accessible Comfort Food Casual Atmosphere

Guest sentiment

What People Feel

A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.

MP
mike pro88 2 month ago

"Great Customer service, the woman working today helped me with my child’s science experience. Very friendly and awesome pizza"

CT
Christine Thilmony 3 month ago

"Great specials available on the app at this Papa John’s location. To advantage of their 2 for $20 special and they did not disappoint. Service was fast and food was hot. Would definitely order again if we’re in the area…"

JM
Jim Martin 3 month ago

"My new favorite thin crust. I was worried it would be spicy because the box eluded to it. Some thin crust pizzas can shred the inside of your mouth they are so thin and crisp. This one was just the right thickness and not too crisp. Great taste too with 2 toppings, mushroom and sausage."

EM
Erica Mendez 4 month ago

"Not bad pricing for Pizza and wings. I love the wing containers that have the spot for your sauce."

CC
Cindy Claeys 5 month ago

"Excellent made pizza. Usually order once a month. Staff has been awesome pizza delicious and made exactly how I ordered it. This Papa Johns has greatly improved in the last two years from the staff inside to the delivery personnel. Thank you all so much."

CP
Christine Popp 5 month ago

"Love the pizza. Would have rated 5 stars but they never cut in squares as I requested. Also, our last pizza was raw dough! We had to reorder and wait another 40 minutes."

E“S
Elizabeth “Liz” Symon 6 month ago

"I want to give them a five star as the ingredients are always fresh and delicious, but they can't seem to get my order right on getting square cut. It's annoying to have to always have them check and find out it's not square cut. They do offer to make you another pizza, but that takes an additional 10-15 minutes to get. If they can get the square cut orders right, I'll gladly update to give stars! Update: Five stars as they have been diligent about checking for square cut. Always delicious, fresh ingredients. Our once or twice a month go to splurge."

AB
Audrey Baker-Robinson 6 month ago

"All I can say is what amazing staff. My husband has been sitting in the parking lot of papa John's for almost 2 hours waiting on a tow truck. Out of no where a young gentleman walked up to my husband with a fresh hot pizza on the house the kid hoped my husband's day gets a little better. That young man brought tears to my eyes, for having such a big heart. Thank you to all the kind staff that made the decision to help brighten my husband's day and to make sure he ate dinner. You are all so very kind, Bless each and everyone of you that worked at 6:30 pm on September 13th. Pizza is delicious"

Visit info

When to Visit

Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.

Today Closed
Weekly hours
Monday 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Tuesday 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Wednesday 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Thursday 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Friday 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Saturday 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Sunday 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Hours may change. Please confirm with the business before visiting.

Best time to visit

The restaurant is open daily from late morning to midnight, ideal for lunch, dinner, or late-night orders.

Open daily 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM Perfect for lunch and dinner Great option for late-night food Quick visits, average 5 minutes Free parking available

On the map

Where This Food Place Lives

Find your way to Papa Johns Pizza in Indiana .

Address 1625 N Michigan St, Plymouth, IN 46563
Phone (574) 936-6500
Area Indiana
Call Address copied ✓

Questions answered

Food Place Questions

Find answers to common questions about Papa Johns Pizza in Plymouth, IN, including menu options, services, and more.

Open daily from 10:00 AM to 12:00 AM, this location offers late-night service throughout the week. Hours may vary during holidays or special occasions.

Yes, services include no-contact delivery, standard delivery, onsite dining, and takeout to accommodate different preferences and safety needs.

Payments can be made using credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. Cash is not mentioned as a payment option.

The restaurant has a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot, ensuring convenience for guests with mobility needs.

Popular choices include the Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, Sausage Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak Pizza, and sides like Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites and Cheesesticks. Desserts like OREO® Cookie Papa Bites are also offered.

Free parking is available both in the lot and on the street, making it convenient for those picking up orders or dining onsite.

Reservations are not accepted. It operates on a first-come, first-served basis or through orders for delivery and takeout.

This location offers a casual atmosphere with counter service. Options include lunch, dinner, and desserts without table service. Typical visits last about 5 minutes, ideal for quick meals or pickups.

For owners

Own or manage this food place?

Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.

Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.